Wagner

Parsifal

Aldenhoff, Mödl, Greindl, Nillius; Kraus
Köln, 1949

Regular price $34.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Parsifal

If you are someone who has always been turned off by the vocal blemishes that marred many of Martha Mödl's performances, then you will probably be very surprised to hear that there was a time (however brief) in which she could really sing. In fact upon first hearing this recording taken in 1949, I was almost convinced that I was hearing a different singer. Mödl sings with a lyricism which suggests that it is possible that she never really was a dramatic soprano, at least vocally speaking. Dramatically, of course, that is a different matter and never one to hold back, Mödl dives into Kundry with an abandon that would set her apart from almost every other singer who ever sang this role. However, unlike many of her later performances, the top notes all come out and with seeming ease. Bernd Aldenhoff manages to match Mödl's lyricism. A young Josef Greindl sings Gurnemanz and reveals a glamor to his voice which wasn't always present as his career progressed. It is also worth pointing out that the Cologne orchestra plays with a romantic sensibility, including the tasteful use of portamenti, that one just doesn't hear from modern orchestras.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.8 Based on 8 reviews
5 ★ 6
4 ★ 2
3 ★ 0
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
Andreas A.✓ Verified Buyer

Switzerland

Overall rating

I love Opera Depot !

My recent order was fulfilled to my complete satisfaction !
Report
Santiago B.✓ Verified Buyer

Spain

Overall rating

Excellent!

Great interpretation, and acceptable sound.
Report
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Update

My copy of disc 4 (Act Three) was defective. Andy replaced it and there are no clicks or glitches now - thank you, Andy!By the way, I meant to write "inflecting and coloring the text" in the main review. Oops.
Report
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Good Performance, Good Sound

The main attraction here is Martha Modl's first documented Kundry. She is already well within the role, infecting and coloring the text as though she had studied the role for years (she probably had). Vocally she is at her freshest with the top A's and B's sung with relative ease, the timbre warm and beautiful. Like most Kundrys, she does all the screams except the one at the end of the Second Act (she would occasionally add this one in later performances).Aldenhoff's vibrato is less annoying here than it would become. He sings with keen awareness of his character. Greindl's voice is more attractive, less gravelly than it would shortly become. His diction and comprehension of his role are never in doubt. Nillius is good, if not great, as Amfortas and Blasius is a terrific Klingsor. The Flowermaidens are exceptional; it would be great to know who they are. Kraus' conducting is capable, the orchestra and chorus excellent. The sound is also very good although there are some minor glitches in the last act (very brief clicking and skipping).If you love Modl, Aldenhoff, Greindl or Parsifal in general this is a recommended purchase.
Report
David M.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Solid if uninspiring Parsifal

Richard Kraus was never a conductor known for his galvanizing interpretations and he leads a safe-but-sane interpretation, highlighted by the solemnity with which he invests the Grail Scene and the pillowy lilt of the waltz section of the Flowermaidens scene. Still, it's a reading seemingly premised on doing Parsifal with as little 'interpretation' as possible.This is a radio-studio performance, meaning that the soloists are miked with Lux Radio Theater claustrophobia. You may not want Josef Greindl right in your ear but there he is, bawling away like Hagen set loose in Montsalvat. Much better notices are deserved for our two protagonists. Bernd Aldenhoff seems a young, ardent Parsifal, veryy touchingly in character and with none of the leathery tone that would begin to mar his word in just a couple of years hence. Also heard in the first bloom of youth is Martha Modl's Kundry, probably her greatest characterization. It's a primeval voice, seemingly hammered out of elemental metals, but all the more powerful for that.Robert Blasius is a stern, restrained Klingsor while Heinrich Nilius' Amfortas never persuades us of anything more than that his side hurts. Placed front and center, Helmut Fehn sounds like a spry Titurel in the prime of life. Sonics, as indicated, are very good indeed.
Report
Angelo R.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

Angelo Raciti

Excellent for the underrecorded Aldenhoff, Mödl's first Kundry and an unexpectedly suave Greindl. Good conducting.
Report
Kevin D.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

Kevin Dunn

This is an astonishing recording. Every element of the performance is first-rate, and the result is a radiant "Parsifal" in which the balance between musical and dramatic expression is achieved to near perfection.
Report
Andrew M.✓ Verified Buyer

Australia

Overall rating

Andrew Murray

Outstanding
Report