Here are the items that we found.
40% Off
The Singers of the New York City Opera
This week we celebrate what would have been the 100th birthday of one of my all-time favorite artists, Leonie Rysanek. Rysanek possessed a voice and dramatic sensibility that can only be described as the definition of larger-than-life.
Born in Vienna in 1926, she made her operatic debut in Innsbruck in 1949. Only two years later, she was chosen to sing Sieglinde in Die Walküre at the historic reopening of the Bayreuth Festival in 1951, appearing in the first postwar Ring production, with performances conducted by Herbert von Karajan. Her electrifying portrayal helped launch an international career that would span the world's great opera houses.
To celebrate her centenary, we're offering 40% off all Leonie Rysanek recordings at Opera Depot.
Newly Remastered
Your Portal to Opera's Grandest Era
The first streaming service devoted entirely to live opera: more than 3,000 performances, carefully remastered and catalogued, with new titles every week.
3,000+ live recordings from $6.67 a month. Founding members save on every annual plan.
Member
BEST VALUECollector
LOSSLESSPatron
ALL ACCESSFeatured Service
FLAC Upgrade Program
There is still time to get the best possible sound out of your collection for a fraction of the price. Upgrade any previous MP3 purchase to the FLAC version and unlock richer sound for some of your favorite recordings.
lossless audio
Free Streaming Recordings
Every week we offer 12 new titles available to stream for free
From Our Collectors
Five-Star Reviews
Opera lovers share their discoveries from the catalogue.
Historical version of Turandot
“Thank you so much for that great version of Turandot !!!!Monserrat Caballé and Birgit Nilsson together !!!!! Amazing !!!!!One of the greatest Turandot with Birgit Nilsson with the most beautiful Liu that we ever heard : Montserrat Caballé”
Beau comme l'Antique
“Crespin atteint ici la hauteur de la grande tragédie classique (comme il convient) avec sa superbe diction . Massard somptueusement tourmenté, Chauvet un poil moins en règle avec le style gluckiste mais très (trop?) vaillant . Sebastian toujours admirable chef de théâtre malgré certains tempi pour nous aujourd'hui trop lents .”
“Dame Janet has been someone I've admired deeply since a child. Anything I could say about her would seem prejudiced. However this collection shows a different and potent side of Dame Janet's art and should be purchased by anyone who treasures this artist. Anything available by Dame Janet is self-recommending.”
Not only Wagner hero, but also "italianità"
“James King became famous in the roles for Heldentenor in Richard Wagner and Richard Strauss. Rare are the testimonies from the beginning of his opera career, when he also took on Italian roles, especially on German and Austrian stages. The present CD documents Macduff's lament from Verdi's Macbeth as well as the two arias and the first great duet from Tosca (with Leonie Rysanek - however, the sound quality here is not good). In the sixties his voice was much more flexible than in his Wagner years, it certainly had the Italianità for these roles, its melancholic touch reminiscent of Franco Corelli. The live recordings of his proven Heldentenor roles are also excellent: Samson, Kaiser (Frau ohne Schatten), Siegmund and Parsifal.”
Delightful Performance With a Great Cast!
“There are opera buffs who will not tolerate an opera sung in anything but its original language. What a pity - they miss out on so much wonderful singing and interpretation! This enchanting performance is sung in very piquant French and is most charming.All of the singers are first-rate. Micheau sings Pamina's big aria with melting beauty while Gedda shows his linguistic skill by singing and speaking in excellent French (he also sang Tamino in German, English, and Italian, perhaps other languages as well). Germain is a lovable Papageno as is Duval as Papagena, both audience favorites. Robin nails all of the Queen's high staccati. I must admit to being a little disappointed that she was overcome with Good Taste and refrained from interpolating any of her notorious B-flats above high C! Arié's smooth-as-silk bass-baritone is almost ideal for Sarastro though he avoids the low F in the first act finale. The supporting cast is equally good as is Sébastian's leadership. The dialogue is spoken with vivacity and is never dull. The announcer sometimes speaks over the music in order to describe the scene to the radio audience, similar to how Milton Cross used to occasionally break in on the old Met broadcasts.The sound is very clear, the pitch of the tape correct. If you love Die Zauberflöte, give La Flûte Enchanté a chance!”
An historic document
“Here's an idiomatic Otello, in which the only Italian is on the podium (Alberto Erede, tautly in charge). This was James King's only performance of Otello in Vienna and he makes a highly dignified Moor of Venice, redeeming some of Boito and Verdi's insufficiency of motivation. King is in terrific voice and if one has heard Helge Roswaenge's Otello, in King one will find a worthy heir to the role. As his ensign, Sandor Solyom-Nagy is not very Italianate of tone quality (he would be shown to greater advantage in the German repertory) but he still makes an effectively insinuating ensign, concealing his villainy behind a veil of bluff sincerity, delivering his most wounding darts as throwaways. Teresa Zylis-Gara is, as ever, an angelic Desdemona, ideal of voice and interpretation. Giuseppe Zampieri's ripe timbre is immediately recognizable as Cassio and Ewald Aichberger is an appropriately puling Roderigo. Some standard cuts are made.The full cast is as follows:Otello: James KingDesdemona; Teresa Zylis-GaraIago: Sandor Solyom-NagyCassio: Giuseppe ZampieriLodovico: Malcolm SmithRoderigo: Ewald AichbergerEmilia: Rohangiz YachmiMontano: Hans ChristianHerald: Georg Tichy”
JÁNOS KÁDÁR
“I bought this CD because I'm a big Rosvaenge fan and I have never heard him in this role. Of course he is excellent as usual though he was 60. It was very interesting to hear his aria in two parts: the first part in the first act while the second one in the third act (where it is sung generally). Fortunately it is not a one man show: the whole ensemble made a very good job though most of the singers are unknown for me. Maria Corelli is a very good Leonora, Gertraud Prenzlow is a really excellent Preziosilla and Kurt Rehm has the level of the greatest baritons in his role. It is really a big surprise and highly recommanded.”
Rare work deserving an audience
“Knew nothing about this opera. Bought it to expand my horizon and was not disappointed. Music is lush and singers give good performances. Recommend to anyone wishing to encounter new work.”
Outstanding recoding
“This recoding of Roberto Devereux truly stands out as a benchmark recoding of this opera. While the Sills/Mackerras studio recoding from 1969 is excellent, this live version easily outshines that. Sills vocal skills are clearly evident here and her ornamentation only adds to the drama of the recording. Having Domingo in the title role is another treat. Hearing his voice at the start of his career in a role he never recorded in the studio further elevates this recording.”
Olivia Stapp at Last!
“Olivia Stapp, whom I was fortunate enough to meet and to converse with, was one of the most promising rising stars of American opera during her vocal prime. Somehow her great potential never materialised into a major international career, i.e. one with a recording contract with a major record label. We are so lucky to have live recordings, like this one, to document her splendour vocally and as an interpreter. I won't say more about this recorded performance. I truly wish to concentrate on its greatest point of uniqueness and greatness. That is Olivia Stapp.”
Donald Honan
“The amazing thing, to me, was that Sutherland never allowed her huge voice to overwhelm Horne [or anyone else] on stage. the duet pieces therefore had all the effect that they should. This was doubly important with Horne, because, unlike Sutherland there has never been anyone else like her. There have been great “coloraturas” & dramatic ones as well, to at least compare to Sutherland in a given role, but not so with Horne. She overreached a few times, but within her domain she appears to have had no rivals, perhaps even in the era before recordings. I heard them in this in 1964 at the old LA Philharmonic. The rest of the cast were throwaways, unfortunately, esp the tenor, but it simply didn’t matter! The entire audience was just stunned. There is a recording from Boston, the next year, that catches it fairly well; I hope this does, too.”
A must for Tinsley fans
“I really enjoyed hearing Pauline Tinsley as Agathe, particularly recorded at such an early date when her voice remained lyric and had yet to acquire the heroic tones to which we are accustomed. Edward Byles was a regular of my early opera experiences with the Welsh National Opera in the early 1970s by which time he was essentially a character tenor. To hear him in his prime, and in such an heroic role, was a real pleasure. Recording quality is good but tends to favour the orchestra over the singers.”
“Tinsley is fearless and totally up to the demands of the role. The only time that I heard her live was as Lady Macbeth - she had everything that the role required, unlike Lise Davidsen's current and very cautious response to its demands.”
Strauss in english?
“Why not? Can´t be worse than Wilde´s play Salome in german (which does not say, that the translation isn´t really good!), and it can certainly not be worse than Hoffmannsthal´s even then more than slightly dusty german. I ordered this out of curiosity - and was by no means disappointed. Armstrong conducts this piece with real confidence and conviction; Tinsley is really good for the most part (sometimes I had to think of Berlioz´"law" for his students: "Never trust a soprano with an important text", but really only at some few points). and Norman Bayley ist just an outstanding Barak. This is a very welcome addition to my collection (Salome I own not only in german, but in italian, swedish, french and english as well), I just could not resist. And its really very listenable. It would not be my first choice (if banned to an island and only allowed to take along a certain number ... and so on; this would still be Böhm, Vienna, 1985), but I´m glad to have it now and highly recommend it ... at least as an addition to one or another recording in the original language.”
One of the all-time great “Otellos”
“In the years 1970-80, the world had three top Otellos: in order of seniority, Jon Vickers, Carlo Cossutta, and Placido Domingo. They all sang more than one revival of the opera at Covent Garden; it was a luxury to compare them then, but now they represent a collective peak never subsequently matched. (Domingo’s Otello, new that decade, continued into the 1990s.) Cossutta’s voice was huge, virile, sexy, baritonal, passionate, and he was the only one of the three to bring Italian diction and placement to the part; I hear here why I adored him then, and surrender again. The surprise of this revival was that Te Kanawa, who had just sung Desdemona at the New York Met with Vickers, seemed to have a voice as large as both Cossutta and Cappucilli. It was the most vocally ample “Otello” I have ever known, and all three voices combined beauty with eloquence. This was the era when Cappucilli moved from his former dull efficiency to a new interpretative intensity: the dark power and easily biting diction of his Iago amazed. But the greatest factor here is Charles Mackerras. Listen to the astounding power of the whole orchestra under the “Sì, pel ciel” duet; and the phenomenal grace of the woodwind at many points; the conviction and sweep of the whole. Colin Davis and Carlos Kleiber conducted superb revivals in those years; I already knew my Toscanini and Serafin recordings; but I understand increasingly now why 1974 reviews said that this was the greatest “Otello” heard since De Sabata.”
Richard Bernas
“This was brilliantly cast with Horne and Verett really well contrasted as Cassandra and Dido. They are both exceptional. Gedda's ease in a difficult role almost conventionalises it; he turns the conflicted hero so thrillingly sung by Vickers and Heppner into a 19th century French Tenor. But it's a legitimate take on the role, and sets it within the tradition. The under-rated Massard is also first rate. I am used to Colin Davis' approach to Berlioz and Pretre is a bit slacker rhythmically, generally less dramatic and severe in his view. Berlioz' roots in Gluck are pretty much ignored. But he doesn't prevent the singers from doing a great job and the orchestra plays well enough.”
Interesting
“The singers are great as expected , the sound is decent but the performance is not as polished as other recordings with the same cast but still a testament of Dame Joan’s virtuosity! 🙃”
Stellar cast, great performance
“There are no weak spots in this cast, and the conducting of Herbert von Karajan is superb. The audio quality is very very good, although the occasional stage noises are a bit distracting.”
EXCELLENT, INTELLIGENT PERFORMANCE
“I'll only add to the judgments below (which I endorse) that this is an unusually intelligent and nuanced performance. The opera's action comes close to the usual Eurocentric portrayal of "exotic" but naive Asians (cf."Butterfly"), and this rendition happily avoids this stereotype. Most notably, Ruth Welting not only hits all the high notes, but portrays a Indian woman who is clearly aware of the issues of this mixed-culture romance. She is especially riveting in the last-act duet, when she becomes keenly aware that her lover Gérard has mixed feelings about staying with her when his regiment goes back to his "home." The excellent Robert Massard, too, portrays Nilakantha not as the usual native thug but as a loving brother, keenly aware of how the British Raj has injured his country and thus fearful for his sister's safety. This is a performance that gets past the vocal high-jinks to get you really thinking about the opera's views on colonialism. (Is it not significant that the Europeans are British, not French?)”
Kubelik's Masterly Meistersinger
“This recording is widely recognized as one of the finest, perhaps THE finest, of Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg. All I can say is that it deserves its high reputation--great singing, and a conductor who paces the opera beautifully.It has been out of print for years and therefore hard to find. When a copy did turn up, the price was exorbitant. So I was delighted to learn that it could be had inexpensively from Opera Depot. No libretto, but that is easily obtainable elsewhere. I also like the packaging, in a soft plastic case with separate slots for each of the four discs, but scarcely thicker than a hard plastic Jewel Case--and it won't shatter if accidentally dropped, as hard plastic cases usually do.I expect I'll be buying more from Opera Depot.”
Exzellente Liveaufnahme aus Wien
“Der Hauptgrund für den Kauf der CD war die Mitwirkung von Reri Grist, eine Sängerin, die Ich sehr schätze, von der es allerdings zu wenige Aufnahmen gibt. Um so erfreulicher der quirlige und lebendige Mittschnitt aus Wien, den auch das Publikum hörbar sehr goutierte, wie man an den Reaktionen während der Aufnahme merkt. Auch Gedda ist hinreißend als Nemorino ebenso Wächter und Kerns. Eine durchweg empfehlenswert Aufnahme in super Sound.”
Opera Depot is that life saver for me
“What an amazing find, Corelli in his prime and singing a poorly written role like it was rain falling off his back. It literally made me cry, it was beautiful and effortless. His Un di all azurro spazio is heroic and the B flats are effortless after sustaining such a low tessitura, and his Come un bel di di maggio is full of pathos and again, such an amazing heroic sound from Sia strofe l'ultima dea to the amazing high B flat on Gelido. Honestly, if you are a Corelli fan, this IS the recording that you need in your collection!Sorry I don't write about the rest of the cast, but Corelli just takes the stage and never relinquishes it.”
A GREAT SURPRISE: TENOR WOLFGANG KASSEL
“Tenor Wolfgang Kassel is the great surprise of this wonderful live recording... A cast of fine singers: Jessye Norman (soprano), Josephine Veasey (mezzo-soprano), Norman Bailey (baritone) and Karl Ridderbusch (bass)... Chorus and Orchestra of the Royal Opera House, London, and a great conductor: Sir Colin Davis... A must!”
location of the Steber Tosca
“The performance was at an arts festival at C.W.Post College on Long Island; there were two performances--Aug 8 and Aug 16; my parents lived on Long Island at the time and I was home from college on summer break before my senior year, and was lucky to go. I no longer know which of the two performances I attended. It was my first live opera, though I was a veteran of many years of Met radio broadcasts from childhood on, mostly thanks to my Italian grandmother.Although I don't think she ever attended a live opera (my grandfather had, to hear Caruso) she loved listening as long as the opera was in Italian or French; German operas got turned off fast. Steber was great. This is not the first time I've found a performance on Opera Depot that has personal memories for me, I'm so thankful for this!”
Martin Ramor
“One one hand here is the problem, that this is very abridged version of Rossini's Otello. It is less than 90 minutes long, on the other hand this is also advantage, because it is more concentrated, with skillful, sensual, even sublime conducting of Arnold Gamson. It was perhaps better to make an abridged version of Otello, since it is beginning of Rossini's revival, to motivate listeners and artists to discover the wonderful world of Rossini. There are some differences with original. For example Iago is baritone Hugh Thompson, who sings very nice. It is a nice joke, bringing nearer Verdi and Rossini. Perhaps was easier to find a good baritone, than to find a third good tenor. Loren Driscoll (tenor) is Rodrigo and does a great job in his role. He was better known as creator of many tenor roles in the operas of 20th century. Farrell as Desdemona and Hayward in the title role are simply amazing. Farrell's Assisa a' piè d'un salice is breathtaking, her coloraturas are good, Heyward sings with great conviction, some stamina and manages coloraturas well.”
This is a really excellent
“This is a really excellent performance of this work. Everyone is in top form. Ghiaurov and Cossotto are well known in these roles and are excellent here. Gencer, Prevedi and Bruscantini never got to record these roles and how wonderful it is to have them here. Gencer always amazes me. She is so unique and marvelous with stupendous pianissimos. Sound is very good.”
Singing-actress
“Every selection on this recording is thrilling, particularly the excerpts from Lulu, Wozzeck, and Salome. One hopes Opera Depot will continue with subsequent volumes of Mme Silja, since her fabled career continued well beyond 1971.”
Sängergeneration der 1970-er Jahre
“Eine sehr schöne Stereo-Aufnahme. Horst Stein dirigiert sehr tempramentvoll undzügig und das Orchester folgt ihm. Manchmal wäre mehr Zeit gerade in der Walküre vortelhaft. Neben den Leistungen von Gustav Neidlinger und Marga Höffgen ist besonders Theo Adam zu nennen. Er singt stimmgewaltig, textverständlich und überzeugt durch eine kraftvolle Interpreteation den Wotan. Helge Brilioth ist weniger strahlend hat hinreißende aber auch anfechtbare Momente ganz im Gegensatz zu Gwyneth Jones. Karl Ridderbusch singt mit warmer herrlich ströhmender sonorer Stimme bleibt aber die Dimension hintergründiger Größe des Hagen schuldig. Catarina Ligendza ist für die erkranke Berit Lindholm im ersten Ring-Zyklus eingesprungen und eroberte sich mit der Partie den internationalen Durchbruch mit einer jugendlichen, weniger typisch hochdramatischen Stimme. Zuverlässig und rollendeckend singt Jean Cox den Siegfried.”
Convincing version
“It is due to Wieland Wagner creating this shortened version for todays use. Adriano sung by a tenor is much more convincing. The cast with Windgassen, Traxel, Neidlinger and Brivcalne was great -- have seen it.”
John Stanton
“Debussy's opera is a work of unusual and distinctive beauty. The distinguished cast here serves it well. Victoria de Los Angeles is a wonderful Melisande, gentle,with a potent sense of a fey, other worldliness. Her Pallas, Pierre Mollet is expressive and gentle. Joseph Rouleau is a steady and dignified Arkel, his voice resonant even in the lowest reaches of the low tessiture of this role. Julian Hass is dramatically rough Goulard, though capable of softening his tone when needed.The sound is very good”
WOW!
“This set is worth hearing just for Zoltan Kelemen's breathtakingly scary Alberich. Truly astonishing. My first experience at the Bayreuth Festival was in 1980 for the final year of this Ring, and the commercially released LPs that followed are still a treasured part of my collection. That later Rheingold can't hold a candle to the sheer visceral excitement generated by this 1976 performance, which is completely in the moment with some of the most rock steady, generous singing I've ever heard in Wagner (either live or on LP/CD). As an aside, track 15 of CD 2 of my copy wouldn't play (Wotan's "Abendlich strahlt..."). I dont know if the same error occurs in the download version, but it certainly doesn't affect my enthusiasm for this set. Magnificent.”
HOW could it miss with a line-up like this
“Some of the best pipes of the last century and every one of them in excellent voice. I read Olivero's thoughts on working with the fledgling Corelli in the book "Franco Corelli, Prince of Tenors" by Rene Segheres. She said he was very very nervous and she made sure she was a soft place for him to land when he was freaking out.... Sweet lady. She also said it was 'perhaps the greatest success of my entire career'. (page 174-5). Highly recommended!!”
The Trojans at Carthage
“If you don't mind having only part of the opera and it being sung in English, then this recording, in excellent sound, can be thoroughly recommended. Janet Baker, as one would expect, is a superb Dido but my main interest was the opportunity to hear Ronald Dowd, a much admired but woefully under-recorded tenor. I well remember him singing Aeneas at a concert performance in London and many other roles, a wholehearted singer always giving good value for money. At one stage, he was considered for the role of Walther in Reginald Goodall's "Mastersingers" before Alberto Remedios was chosen. It would have been interesting to hear Dowd's no doubt very different interpretations of that and other Wagner roles. But "Rowdy Dowdy" might not have been amenable to Goodall's meticulous training regime! I can also recommend his performances in Tristan and Die Walkure Act 1, both available from Opera Depot. In this recording, the other singers, orchestra and conductor all acquit themselves well.”
Gene in LA
“I had the good fortune to see the New York City Opera’s production in L.A., with Norman Bailey as Sachs, Johanna Meier as Eva and the great, greatly-missed John Alexander as Walther. Julius Rudel conducted. I believe NYCO was borrowing the English National Opera production, done in Andrew Porter’s English as The Mastersinger. It was quite possibly the greatest single opera performance I’ve ever seen.”
Fantastic Fidelio
“Absolutely brilliant. It is only a fragment but a valuable fragment at that. Currently one is unable to get hold of a Toscanini Fidelio anywhere. I am a collector of historical live recordings of opera and have been collecting performances from the 1935-37 Salzburg festival for a long time when Bruno Walter and Arturo Toscanini were at the helm. Toscanini had refused to conduct at Bayreuth anymore following Hitler's rise to power and had moved to Salzburg. These performances are legendary and some eminent conductors such as Georg Solti learned their craft under the great conductor. I already have performances of Die Zaberflotte, Falstaff and Die Meistersinger and they are all fab. This completes the set. Other than Toscanini, the performance is notable for the wonderful performance of Lotte Lehmann who sang the role of Leonore. I have 78s and CDs of her commercial recordings but nothing can replace a live recording. If you are happy to listen to recordings in decent sound for the time, this is well worth a listen. Wouldn't it be great if one day somebody could find a complete performance of this opera”
Near divinity!
“This is my third copy of this recording. I keep giving them to my opera nut friends.Wverything about this recording is superb! Kleiber, of course, makes you feel that you have left this world and joined Strauss in his.”
Excellent Document!
“This is an excellent document! USF, Rysanek and Varnay is luxury casting. I also love how the recording gives you a strong sense of space. When the singers are far from the microphone, there is echoing which adds to the acoustic effect. When the voices are near the mic they sound lush and warm. Another revelation for me, after listening to so many Elektras -- is that the clarinet and winds were never so present as in this recording. Sometimes I never even thought they were there. But once I heard them, it somehow adds some comic effect to the music. Is it just me? There are two instances of audio being cut. Like in the instrumental procession before Klytemnestra's entrance. But that is just fine, given that this recording is so precious!”
Forgot how great this opera is!
“While working on my Bachelor's in music composition, I came across the Solti DVD of Bartók's "Bluebeard" at a secondhand shop in Eastern New Mexico. I bought the DVD not knowing anything about the opera and instantly became obsessed. I studied the opera somewhat in depth while working on my Master's degree and just about forgot about it after that. When Opera Depot had their recent Birgit Nilsson sale, I saw this was one of the offerings and thought I'd give it a try for two reasons: 1.) Birgit Nilsson singing the role of Judith! and 2.) memories of how much I loved the opera. I was a bit hesitant at first that it was sung in German, but that is such a minor quibble. I think the sound is great and I'm very thankful to have a recording of Nilsson singing this piece. I am happy with the purchase and am glad to be reminded how great this music is! Huge thanks to Opera Depot for their array of live recordings!”
Charlie Edwards
“I have recordings of nearly every singer in his or her role in other recordings, so why go for this one? Every member of the cast is in amazingly fresh and easy voice. Windgassen's best Loge without doubt, as the voice is ductile and commanding in a way not found on the Böhm or Furtwängler recordings (he is in tired voice by 1966 and seems less alive in Rome in 1953.) Frantz is his usual self, but perhaps more imposing and much better recorded by Hamburg Radio. Neidlinger remains a non-pareil of an Alberich - saturnine, menacing, vivid. Amazing vocal acting and completely unaffected by being in a studio rather than on a stage. I disagree with the other reviewer about Res Fischer - I find her full of character and her tone is interesting. As far as I know it's the only evidence of her in the role, and she is a rather poorly represented singer in terms of recordings, a dazzling Klytaemnestra a year later with Varnay, Hotter and Rysanek (!!) aside. I love Schüchter's way with the score - a real Schauspiel and well played by the excellent orchestra. The two giants are magnificent and perfectly cast. I always thought it a mistake that Furtwängler cast them in opposite roles in Rome - Frick is much better suited to the gentle Fasolt, and Greindl owned every note Fafner ever has to sing. The only weird thing is that Res Fischer sings Erda as well as Fricka, though some engineering was done to try to distance her voice as Erda. Surely there were plenty of deep voiced contraltos around Hamburg in 1952? Where was Maria von Ilosvay... oh wait, in the Rhine with her sisters!”
Strauss: Elektra - Nilsson, Bjoner, Varnay, Esser, Crass; Sawallisch. München, 1972
“Die Wiedergabequalität ist sehr schlecht und nur wenn man unbedingt nostalgische Gefühle hegt sollte man die Aufnahme kaufen. Das Sängerensemble ist ein Traum mit den besten Solisten dieser Zeit (1972). Nilsson und Varnay gibt es mit besserer Qualität zu hören.----------------------------------------------------------------The reproduction quality is very poor and you should only buy the recording if you have nostalgic feelings. The ensemble of singers is a dream with the best soloists of the time (1972). Nilsson and Varnay can be heard in better quality.”
A Memoerable Frau, but January 77, not October
“This performance is not from the run of performances in October 1977 that were used in the DGG CD issue, all of which featured James King, as per the Staatsoper online archive, which also shows that the only Frau performances sung by Mattu Kastu were 16, 20 and 27 January 1977. Nevertheless it is a fabulous performance, very likely 27 January, the unforgettable perfomance I attended.”
Covent Garden debuts of Tebaldi & Tagliavini
“This production was Tebaldi’s official CG debut. Previously, she sang Desdemona on a La Scala tour to CG in 1950. These would be her only CG appearances. This was also Tagliavini’s CG debut. His only return engagement would occur the following season, partnering Milanov in her CG debut as Tosca. Here, Tebaldi is impetuous and imperious, captured in her effulgent prime. Tagliavini may be a shade light, singing with vigor if not complete abandon. Gobbi’s dramatic profile is definitive, and his singing has a youthful sheen. Molinari-Pradelli leads with energy and polish. Sound excellent.”
Carol and Placidó ride again into the sunset!
“This performance from London's Royal Opera finds most of the cast included in the DG recording of this production, intact and at white heat. Everyone is firing on all cylinders - such a great demonstration of verismo at work. Carol Neblett is in perfect voice, scaling the heights and depths of the vocal line with fearless attacks and deep involvement. I just love the sumptuous middle register and fierce top register. A favorite Minnie captured for all time. Her being a California native does inform her emotional palette. The strength of her tone reads in all registers with heated emotions in place and still audible over the heavy orchestration. And that poker game....Exciting! Placidó is giving his all at the summit of vocal powers with emotional connection to the text and his relating to the plot actions in moment after moment. The stunning power and beauty of his vocal capabilities are on full display with a generous emotional and musical offering. Silvano Carroli, as Rance, demonstrates a bite in his character and vocal line while snarling, still displaying a roundness of tone. With these principals and excellent support from the depth of the ROH company, every bit of tension and beauty is evident. A great performance! And Zubin Mehta is the perfect leader for the constant shifts of tempi, orchestration, a superb orchestra and chorus at his command, and a surefire understanding of tempo and shading to the confident development of the plot. A masterful support of all the artists and drama in this emotional performance. One feels wrung out, in the best of ways. Do get this performance. It will be one of the best in your collection. Sound is very good with just slight distortion at the loudest peaks..but not bothersome.”
Wonderful Butterfly from a wonderful soprano !
“My first performance at the Vienna Staatsoper was April, l973, Madama Butterfly starring Lotte Rysanek, a soprano I knew from her many operetta recordings from the Volksoper. I was mightily impressed with Lotte. This l972 performance verifies my memories of that 1973performance. It is uncanny the resemblance to her sister Leonie's voice, a glorious and soaring top included. At times I would swear I was hearing Leonie singing Butterfly. Thrilling! Needless to say Leonie is one of my favorite sopranos and I did manage to hear Leonie at least half a dozen times before her retirement. Sound is quite satisfying.”
Blimey!
“Before buying this Opera Depot version, I have had at least four other versions (and probably one or two I've forgotten), got shot of most (no names) and kept IDIS and Myto (though I think Myto actually has the edge). Now, I may as well toss these other two because this OP edition is stunning. Admittedly, a lot depends on one's play-back system, but I have seldom heard Callas sound so natural. Often recordings emphasize the edge in her voice and lose the rich undertones. Not here. I am SO glad to have this, and I bought several copies to give to friends. I leave it to you to decide but, if I were you, I'd buy it now!”
Deutekom an exciting Elena
“First of all, I couldn't be happier with the sound. It's very good in-house house from audience sound. It has always bothered me that Deutekom was not credited as the exciting performer she was. As she matured vocally, the voice retained it's brightness but increased it's BRILLIANT edge and plants and chest tones. All vocal elements needed to express character and drama are there. The coloratura rates as drop dead exciting. Bonisli is in top voice. And, the conductor pulls astounding power, nuance and rhythmic here He from the orchestra. THANKS!”







