Massenet

Werther (In Italian)

Olivero, Lazzari, Panni, Meletti; Rossi
Torino, 1963

Regular price $17.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Werther

Although Werther will always be a vehicle for a star tenor, a great mezzo (or in this case soprano) in the role of Charlotte can easily steal the show. After all, the real conflict in this opera exists within Charlotte's desire to be with Werther against her sense of duty to her husband. Magda Olivero creates a tour-de-force performance (as she often did) which does in fact walk away with the show. In all honesty, this is due in part to the lack of a Werther who could match her artistry, and although Agostino Lazzari sings admirably, it is not at the same level as Olivero who is magnetic.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

5.0 Based on 4 reviews
5 ★ 4
4 ★ 0
3 ★ 0
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
Robert C.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Top Notch

Werther 1963, Manon Lescaut 1970, Tosca 1957, La Wally 1972 - all featuring Magda Olivero are glorious listening.
Report
John C.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Werther

Great performance in great sound.
Report
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Great Performance, Excellent Sound!

Charlotte (Carlotta in Italian) is not a role that one would normally associate with Olivero; I have no idea whether or not she did the role on stage. But she invests every moment with specific emotion. One usually hears "general joy" or "general fear": not with Olivero. Her outburst on Sophia's departure in the last scene may be considered too much by some; I think it's especially poignant and entirely appropriate. Nor does she go over the top in the last scene, keeping her tears to a minimum. A classic portrayal, very different from Nina Vallin's cooler, more austere approach on the classic studio recording with Georges Thill.Andy finds Lazzari adequate, but not up to Olivero. I think he's wonderfully sensitive and poetic, singing with equal parts grace and passion. I was surprised he ducks the high B towards the end of Werther's Act Two monologue, but it may not have been printed in the score he was using. His death scene responses match Olivero every step of the way. Meletti is a subtle, almost sinister Albert and Panni a lovely Sophia. Rossi's conducting brings out the drama without milking the emotions too much. I regret he makes the traditional cut in the last scene where the children and Sophia are heard singing offstage. Werther is not a long opera - go figure!The sound is not only very good, but genuine stereo with excellent separation of the voices and instruments. This is a must for Olivero fans!
Report
Frank L.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Frank Leto

very nice performance. i love werther and this was a fine performance. Italian no problem for french production.
Report