Bizet

Carmen

Resnik, Uzunov, Güden, Protti; Karajan
Wien, 1961

Regular price $17.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Carmen

The usually meticulous, cerebral baton of Herbert von Karajan would seem like an odd match for Bizet's Carmen, but he leads the forces of the Wiener Staatsoper in a lively, well-sung performance that gives real weight to the opera's theme of despair. Leading the cast is Regina Resnik, predictably thrilling in the final duet and surprisingly idiomatic and seductive in the role's more beguiling passages. "Idiomatic and seductive" can't really describe her Don José, Bulgarian tenor Dimiter Uzunov, but he wields a powerful instrument and uses it for more than just blasting notes out. Hilde Güden is the plaintive, beautifully sung Micaëla and Aldo Protti an impressive-sounding but rather out-of-place Escamillo. The chorus, singing in German, does impressive work, and the Zuniga of Ludwig Welter is also worthy of note.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.3 Based on 4 reviews
5 ★ 2
4 ★ 1
3 ★ 1
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Karajan and Resnik are a Potent Combination!

This performance comes from a time just before the Vienna State Opera became internationalized. The chorus was still singing everything in German and the soloists sang (usually) in the original language. Resnik is an exciting presence as Carmen. When she steps on stage, someone has arrived and it makes sense that all the men are going crazy about her. She is in far better voice here than in Opera Depot's other performance with her (from 1967). Uzonov will probably be no one's favorite tenor: the vibrato is too noisy, the style sweaty and graceless - and yet he certainly does have his moments (the ringing interpolated top C at the end of Act Two one of them). Protti is a loud, boisterous Escamillo with amusing French, Gueden a lovely if occasionally unsteady Micaela. I love how Karajan gives Mercedes and Frasquita each a verse of the Gypsy Song that opens Act Two (Resnik gets the last verse). He also interpolated a ballet into Act Four, but many companies did that then (some still do).If you want to hear Resnik in her best voice in this role, get this. It's not a very French performance perhaps, but it's fun and exciting and transports one back to a time in opera history when that was OK.
Report
Guenter S.✓ Verified Buyer

Austria

Overall rating

Guenter Schober

super and historical
Report
Erich R.✓ Verified Buyer

Austria

Overall rating

Erich Ruthner

a beautifull thing
Report
Stéphane B.✓ Verified Buyer

France

Overall rating

Stéphane BONNEAU

Strange...
Report