Wagner

Rienzi

Mitchinson, Haywood, McDonnall, Langdon, Herincx, Ward; Downes
London, 1976

Regular price $34.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Rienzi

Although Rienzi is not quite up to the artistic level of Wagner's "mature works", the piece has many memorable moments and an overall energetic, youthful drive to it that reminds me of early Verdi. Similar to Verdi's early works, there is also a strong patriotic component which makes for some stirring choruses and ensembles as well as some beautiful arias, in addition to the famous "Prayer", including Adriano's "Gerechter Gott…" This cast of mostly Brits does an excellent job pulling off the performance. At nearly four hours of music, this is likely one of the most complete Rienzis available (it even included ensembles not in the vocal score I was following.) In the theater this work would most certainly need to be cut, but with the luxury of being able to advance to the next track, this recording is a very interesting window into Wagner's early composition technique. John Mitchinson brings a burly tone and solid technique to the title role. Lorna Haywood is a stand-out as Adriano. The purity of her voice gives her credibility in a pants role and her lush voice serves her well during the dramatic moments of a character that can be considered a proto-Elsa of sorts. Edward Downes leads a performance that favors broad tempi without shortchanging the energetic and rousing ensembles.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.4 Based on 10 reviews
5 ★ 7
4 ★ 1
3 ★ 1
2 ★ 1
1 ★ 0
John Q.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

Excellent performance

This is a fine studio performance from the BBC in Manchester from 1976. The singing from all the cast is very fine, with standouts being Lorna Haywood as Adriano and John Mitchinson in the title role. However, the star is Edward Downes, a much under-recorded conductor, who holds this mighty, sprawling piece together and transforms it into a gripping drama.
Report
Michael B.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

Rare version

It is excellent and besides this the most comprehensive recording of the piece. I only wished that you would also publish a new version of the recording of Wagner´s Die Feen by Downes as well.
Report
Warren P.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Not the Original

This item is the stereo original recording. This is a mono recording which is ok, but the product is a knock off. On the flip side, the official release is quite expensive if you can find it, running over $100, so you get what you pay for.
Report
Virginia G.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Edward Downes Rienzi

Performance of the Downes’ Rienzi was excellent but the sonics were disappointingly poor, worse in some parts than others. At some points it sounded like a 1930s or 1940s recording, very harsh and shrill sound, no transparency in the orchestra. A real shame, as all those extra choruses and ballet music are (or should be) a treat to hear. I’ve seen reports that there have been both stereo and mono versions of this recording out there. The MP3s supplied with the CDs show this recording as Joint Stereo, which I believe is sometimes used as an attempt to add presence to mono recordings. Interestingly, there is a version of the Downes Rienzi on YouTube, and I have to say, sonically it seems to be better than this pressing. For a 1976 performance, I was expecting a much higher quality of sound.
Report
Gary G.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Well done!!

Very timelyExcellent coffee ntent
Report
Keith G.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

Rienzi - Downes, London, 1976

Excellent performances from John Mitchinson, Lorna Haywood and Lois McDonnell. The recording is in decent mono sound and, despite a bit of congestion in some of the louder passages in Act 1, presents the voices in a realistic and clear acoustic. I have two other (commercial) recordings of Rienzi and this one is by far the longest (by about 1 hour!) and the most enjoyable. It is the one I will be returning to most frequently for the individual performances and the excellent conducting. Thank you for making this astonishing document available.
Report
Dr M.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Rienzi

This is truly a legendary performance of Rienzi by Edward Downes, which deserves all the praise it has received over the last 42 years. Thanks to Opera Depot for making it available again on CD.Dr Michael Humble
Report
Berniard M.✓ Verified Buyer

France

Overall rating

The "young" Wagner

A recording truely completewhich cannot be found in France. Thank you very much.
Report
Boyd C.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Boyd Cathey

This is the most complete recording of Wagner's early opera, RIENZI, available. It was a BBC broadcast performance (1976), and it was from that broadcast that this presentation was eventually derived. For a time, it was available on the Ponto label. On all counts it is a solid presentation, in decent and quite acceptable sound. John Mitchinson, the eponymous major character has a good voice, and he doesn't seem to tire, despite the length of the work. His show-stopping aria/scene "Almacht'ger Vater" is well handled. While Mitchinson doesn't compare to a Lauritz Melchior as a heldentenor (who does?), he does quite well. The release also gives us all (or most) of the beautiful ballet music. Ths incarnation includes ample cue listings. This is a valuable release, strongly recommended to those who enjoy grand opera and its development.
Report
Joseph B.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

Joseph Brand

A unique account of Wagner's 'grand opera'. It is the most complete you will ever hear. No other commercial version on cd or dvd is anything like as complete so give a false impression of the opera. A splendid cast of British singers perform under the baton of Edward Downes - one of the greatest opera conductors of the 20th century sadly ignored by all the major record labels. Essential listening - even the famous overture has passages you've never heard before.
Report