Beethoven

Fidelio (CONTAINS DISTORTION)

A. Konetzni, Pataky, Berglund, Gutmann; E. Kleiber
Buenos Aires, 1937

Regular price $17.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Fidelio

In the interests of full disclosure, I will lead with the fact that this performance is from 1937, when recording from the radio was still in its infancy. Although there are stretches of perfectly listenable music, the biggest flaw is that there is a good deal of distortion at the upper ranges of volume. This particularly affects Anny Konetzni’s colossal soprano voice. So why would I release it, you ask? Well, normally it wouldn’t have made it, but a complete performance of Fidelio conducted by Erich Kleiber, replete with the Leonore #3 overture is such an important document that I didn’t have the heart to withhold it due to some (pretty substantial) flaws in the sound. So I invite you all to view this as you would an ancient Roman Fresco. If you listen carefully you will hear an incredibly spirited performance from Kleiber as well as some astonishing singing from Konetzni. Konetzni, despite having an enormous instrument, sounds as if she would be just as at home singing the Countess in Le Nozze di Figaro. Additional kudos go to Koloman von Pataky for his lyrical Florestan. But don’t say I didn’t warn you about the sound…

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.6 Based on 5 reviews
5 ★ 3
4 ★ 2
3 ★ 0
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Excellent Performance in Challenging Sound!

Andy is very honest about the sound on this set. The distortion is annoying, but once the ear adjusts the sound is listenable although I wouldn't recommend this set to anyone who isn't accustomed to early radio sound. I wish the distortion wasn't there, but there we are. The pitch is correct though and given the challenges of preserving a recording like this, that's an achievement.Kleiber drives his forces to the point of frenzy. There is an urgency here uncommon in other performances of this opera. The playing of the Leonore #3 in the second act is worth the price of admission alone. Konetzni lives up to her reputation with her huge, colorful voice. Like her sister Hilde she is top note challenged. She fakes her high Bs in the big aria expertly; if you want terrific high notes you must look elsewhere (she's good up to B-flat). Von Pataky is a wonderful Florestan with his beautiful, lyric timbre. Joel Berglund is a frightening Pizarro who sings extremely well. Editha Fleischer is a charming Marcelline (she sang Hänsel in the first 1931 Met broadcast) and Karl Laufkötter is a vivid Jaquino (were they on loan from the Met?). Rocco's aria in Act 1 is cut (a traditional cut at that point). The chorus and solo prisoners sing in Italian.This is only for aficionados of the opera or the performers, but for those who can tolerate the sound it's worth the effort.
Report
Bjorn A.✓ Verified Buyer

Denmark

Overall rating

Wonderful historic Live

Some distortion of sound, but strong performances not to be found elswhere. Especially Joel Berglund. What a voice
Report
Namie T.✓ Verified Buyer

Japan

Overall rating

Bad sound, yes, but I

Bad sound, yes, but I enjoyed Joel Berglund.
Report
Gunther T.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

Gunther Teckelmann

Great, because Pataky, Berglund and Kleiber participate in this recording
Report
Peter Z.✓ Verified Buyer

Austria

Overall rating

Peter Zimmermann

One of the most interesting Fidelios in now some better sound as before
Report