Wagner

Tristan und Isolde

Wenkoff, Ligendza, Minton, McIntyre, Ridderbusch; C. Kleiber
Bayreuth, 1976

Regular price $26.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Tristan und Isolde

Given that Tristan und Isolde was one of the few operas Carlos Kleiber conducted regularly, it is fortunate that several recordings exist to document his interpretation. Most of these feature Catarina Ligendza as Isolde. Her voice, though lighter than many who take on the role, is managed with admirable control and stamina, allowing her to carry the part through to the end with poise.

For me, the true centerpiece of these performances is Spas Wenkoff as Tristan. His voice has a burnished quality, and his breath control is nothing short of extraordinary. He brings a tortured emotional intensity—never strained vocally—that fits the role perfectly. Kleiber’s conducting is consistently fresh and inspired, revealing nuances that set these performances apart from the more familiar DG release.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.9 Based on 38 reviews
5 ★ 35
4 ★ 2
3 ★ 1
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
Olivier F.✓ Verified Buyer

Switzerland

Overall rating

The miracle of Bayreuth

Kleiber, orchestra, singers = perfection !
Report
D. R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Searing Performance Captured in Excellent Sound!

So many other writers have reviewed this performance here that I won't spend a lot of time on it except to say if you love this opera this is a performance you don't want to miss. Spas Wenkoff was considered a second stringer at the Met and elsewhere back in the late 70s and 80s when he was in his vocal prime. We must've been nuts to take him for granted, but we did. His performance here is superb. He and Kleiber give us one of the most memorable performances of Act Three I've ever heard. Not so incidentally, Ligendza sings an extra top B-flat in her "Ich bins" monologue, a note misprinted in current vocal scores. Why more Isoldes don't make the change I don't know (it was also sung by Margaret Price in Kleiber's frustratingly stillborn studio recording).The entire cast is superb as is the orchestra. Kleiber's intensity drives everyone almost to the breaking point. I don't say his interpretation is better than Furtwängler's, Böhm's, Knappertsbusch's or even his own father's, but it certainly matches the best of them. The sound is excellent throughout. This is what opera as music drama is all about.
Report
Roy P.✓ Verified Buyer

Australia

Overall rating

2 of the three discs simply would not play

Disc 2, the only one of the 3 that would play, was a very good recording of a great performance,
Report
William W.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Terrific Performance of Tristan und Isolde

This is from a 1976 broadcast from the Bayreuth Festival. It is available on YouTube. Of the Tristan recordings I have heard or sampled, this is by far my favorite performance. The sound quality is also excellent.Nevertheless, I have some reservations, which is why I am giving 4 stars instead of 5. The three CDs correspond to the three acts of the opera. The volume level of CD2 is significantly lower than that of the other two CDs, so you need to adjust your volume for Act 2. Each CD ends with absurdly long applause, unsuitable for home listening, so you will want to cut it short once the applause starts.The track listing does not include the track timings. On CD1, there is an abrupt and jarring skip when track 4 starts.Neither a libretto nor program notes are included.
Report
Braco V.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Best recording of this work

This s the best recording of this work, better than Kleiber’s recording on DG.
Report
Frank L.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Get This Now

This is a fantastic Tristan. Kleiber is an exciting conductor and Wenkoff an excellent Tristan. The sound is wonderful. Do yourself a favor nd buy this Tristan.
Report
Manuel A.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

A wonderful passionate performance!

The pormance was great. The singers were in great voice. The conducting was great. Carlos klieber really has this opera in his blood. I l love that the applause was included. You can really tell the audience lived it. The sound was excellent too!. This performance was better than his commercial recording.
Report
Dieter G.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

Eine legendäre Aufnahme

Kleibers Dirigat ist elektrisierend.Ligendza eine jugendlich tönende Isolde.So ganz kann Wenkoff da nicht mithalten. Bewältigt aber, mitgerissen von seiner Partnerin, gut die mörderische Partie.Alle anderen Singen ebenfalls auf höchstem Festspielniveau. Neben der Aufnahme aus der 60ern mit Böhm, Nilsson Windgassen das Beste was ich kenne!
Report
Peter F.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

A Masterpiece

Sviatoslav Richter on Kleiber's Tristan in Bayreuth in 1976 ..as long as I live I shall never hear another Tristan like this one. This was the real thing... There's no doubt he's the greatest conductor of our day.” So I just had to hear this. Many thanks
Report
Kenneth B.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

One of the best performances of Tristan

It's a great performance all around. Unfortunately, Act Two the sound is more distant. Nonetheless a must recording for all.
Report
Charles E.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

The best of Kleiber in this piece...

This must be by far the best recording I have heard of Kleiber in this extraordinary piece. He, by 1976, had stabilised his view of the piece and the Bayreuth orchestras has become accustomed to his fantastically seductive and impassioned podium activities! Compare this with, for instance, the Vienna 1973 shambles, where the sloppy orchestra and conductor are often at odds, the cast sounds under-rehearsed, especially Neidlinger and Hopf, who all but ruins the performance with his stolid, pasty singing. Ligendza for me is always something of a liability to be honest - what would we have done for the Brünnhilde of that 1976 festival as Isolde - Gwyneth Jones, with whom Kleiber worked really well on 'Rosenkavalier'. I totally agree that Wenkoff is at his very best here. I saw this extraordinary singer as a frenzied an possessed Tannhäuser in the theatre. He is amazing here in Act 3 especially. He is at one with what Kleiber is up to at all times, and sings for his life in the last act! McIntyre as ever a sensitive and terribly moving Kurwenal. This must be among the greatest bits of operatic conducting ever to have been immortalised on tape. Thank heavens for Bavarian Radio!!
Report
Thomas W.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Get this!!!!!

What is they to say? This is splendid in every way. And probably the best of the Tristans during the time of Carlos Kleiber.
Report
Keith G.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

EXCEPTIONAL MUST HEAR/BUY

If this had been around when I bought my first recording back in the early 1970s (Bohm's recorded in 1966 in Bayreuth) I doubt I would ever have felt a need to seek out any other recordings. It is a truly magnificent performance. I read recently that Kleiber spent much time before the initial run in 1974 studying the score in minute detail as well as exploring every aspect of the Bayreuth Festspielhaus familiarising himself with the sound of the place. It shows. Act 2 has a miraculous stillness to it contrasting the amazing tension in Act 1 and the desperation in Act 3. Wenkof in Act 3 is unequalled by anyone anywhere and Ligendza unleashes a gloriously full, bright, unforced sound in the Liebestod. It's a must have.
Report
Enrico G.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

what a Bayreuth year: Boulez's 'Ring' and Kleiber's Tristan'

Exciting, surprising, at lengths leaving you breathless, but always extremely thought-through orchestrally (after listening to a recording Kleiber's 1974 Tristan and Isolde in Bayreuth, even if soundwise much poorer than this one, I threw Böhm's Bayreuth recording away).
Report
Ken R.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

One of the truly great performances

I was fortunate to actually have attended this performance. It was a thrill to hear it again in all its glory. Ligendza and Wenkoff were the perfect pair (vocally and physically), and Carlos Kleiber's electrifying conducting of the stellar Bayreuth orchestra was breath-taking. The orchestra sounded glorious. I had never heard of Spas Wenkoff before, but he struck me as a true Heldentenor, with a rich, powerful, almost baritone voice. I was also impressed with his acting ability (the contrast of his beautiful and powerful voice in Acts 1 and 2 to the weakness portrayed in Act 3 while mortally wounded comes across well in this recording). Ligendza was a perfect Isolde, looking and sounding the part. While I loved Nilsson in this role, Ligendza has a more feminine, subtle and vulnerable performance. This recording does that magical day justice. My only critique would be the volume level for the second act seems slightly lower than the other two, but that might just be my playback equipment.One final personal note: I remember being so stunned by this performance that I walked back to my hotel oblivious to the fact it was raining. I enthusiastically recommend this recording! I hope you find it as thrilling as I did.
Report
Juerg V.✓ Verified Buyer

Switzerland

Overall rating

Phantastic

It's a great and overwelming performance in a excellent sound!
Report
Ray S.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

Fabulous Tristan buy

My favourite Wagner opera and I wasn’t disappointed with this 76 Bayreuth performance under Kleiber. He gets everything right and the lead performers are on top form. Wenkoff is outstanding especially in Act 3. You won’t be disappointed. Great purchase.
Report
Mark C.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Outstanding!!

Terrific performance in Bayreuth’s characteristically clear acoustic. Kleiber is a phenomenon with this score; Ligendza & Wenkoff both brilliantly characterful, vibrantly dramatic & deeply musical.
Report
Julian S.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

wonderful recording

Great sound quality and a Ligendza Isolde to die for (sorry about the pun), but this is really a unique take of the role and one that many Tristan lovers will enjoy.
Report
Matsumoto S.✓ Verified Buyer

Japan

Overall rating

good job!

It is like a dream.
Report
David M.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

A triumph for Kleiber

This is Tristan as a fever dream, as the vehement sforzandi in the Prelude tell us. Throughout the performance the secret ingredient in Carlos Kleiber's interpretation is scrupulous fidelity to Wagner's markings, executing with terrifying passion and precision by the Bayreuth Festival Orchestra, in glorious sound. Of the principals, only Yvonne Minton is quite on Kleiber's level and even she finds Einsam wachend a bit high for maximum effect. Donald McIntyre is a rough and ready Kurwenal (emphasis on rough) while Karl Ridderbusch coasts through King Marke on superior vocal endowment. As for our lovers, Caterina Ligendza is more at home in wrath than love: You might say she favors the day side of the opera's day/night symbolic axis. She paces herself well through the role, although any note above the staff glares harshly. Spas Wenkoff's Tristan is virile, more knight than poet, but he stays the course with admirable durability (Kleiber makes no cuts.) A few lines get dropped or bobbled -- live performance, you know -- but the Bayreuth audience is understandably electrified by what they're witnessing.
Report
John F.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Perhaps my favorite Tristan

This is, I believe, my favorite recording of Tristan. The music washes over you in the prelude; the lines are beautifully sculpted. This is a very dramatic orchestra. Ligendza is fully captivating as Isolde. Really a wonderful cast all around.
Report
Andrew G.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Excellent. Kleiber mesmerizing, especially in

Excellent. Kleiber mesmerizing, especially in the third act (which shows off the orchestra better than Acts 1 and 2). The supporting cast is first rate and Wenkoff is magnificent--a deeply committed performance and a beautiful voice. Ligenza is very feminine, but her light voice becomes unpleasant under pressure and her top is shrill. Even so, we'd be grateful to hear the part so well sung in the opera house today. Sound is first rate, studio quality.
Report
Miguel G.✓ Verified Buyer

Mexico

Overall rating

Miguel Garcia

Excellent version!
Report
Robert F.✓ Verified Buyer

Austria

Overall rating

Robert Fucik

#best 1970 cast imanginable; best conductor ever
Report
Bruce G.✓ Verified Buyer

Canada

Overall rating

Bruce Gillespie

Top-notch performances, great sound quality
Report
Dieter S.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

Dieter Schulze

fantastic
Report
Alexander N.✓ Verified Buyer

Russia

Overall rating

Alexander Nedashkovsky

Spas Wenkoff and Catarina Ligendza - this stunning duo! Carlos Kleiber - a great expert on Tristan!
Report
C T.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

C W TAYLOR

A thrillingly dramatic, and theatrical performance. Probably the best of Kleiber's Bayreuth Tristans. Wenkoff a powerful presence more than Brilioth in '74 and'75.
Report
John Q.✓ Top Reviewer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

John Querns

The great Carlos Kleiber conducts Tristan und Isolde. Is a review necessary? That should be enough of a recommendation. Buy it.
Report
Robert P.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Robert Pokorny

Excellent
Report
Vincenzo S.✓ Verified Buyer

Italy

Overall rating

Vincenzo Scerra

The reading of Boulez is quite original and some singer as Mc Intyre is not right for the role.
Report
Martin R.✓ Top Reviewer

Slovenia

Overall rating

Martin Ramor

Well - it is great Tristan, I am glad that I bought it.
Report
Robert D.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

Robert Dean

An electrifying performance with Kleiber at the height of his considerable powers
Report
Francois M.✓ Verified Buyer

Romania

Overall rating

Francois Martini

A must have !
Report
Giovanni M.✓ Verified Buyer

Italy

Overall rating

giovanni martini

Sublime interpretation in the urgency of a vibrant beauty passion; singers, chorus and orchestra, in clear connection with the will of Kleiber: Absolute unreachable!
Report
Kenji M.✓ Verified Buyer

Japan

Overall rating

kenji maeda

This performance is the best all of Tristan ever heard. Kleiber conducted with delicacy and passion, and Wenkoff and Ligendza are best pair of Tristan and Isolde. All Wagnerian should be have this Splendid performance.
Report
L'héritier B.✓ Verified Buyer

France

Overall rating

L'Héritier Boris

Sublime!
Report