Wagner

Siegfried

Windgassen, Hotter, Shuard, Stolze; Solti
London, 1965

Regular price $34.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Siegfried

This recording is particularly fascinating as it reunites much of the cast from the 1962 recording for a chance to hear them unfettered by Solti's insistence on multiple takes as he notoriously insisted upon in the studio. The result is certainly a performance that, although lacking in the same level of polish, breathes organically and seems in many ways effortless. Wolfgang Windgassen's youthful tenor was one of the best at conveying a teenager in this role. Hans Hotter offers a world-weary Wanderer. Once again Gerhard Stolze nearly steals the show as Mime. Can anyone name a better character tenor in the history of opera? Amy Shuard starts out strong but seems to tire as the opera comes to a close, opting out of the last high C. It is a small price to pay considering how mellifluously she spins "Ewig war ich" almost as if she were singing a Mozart aria.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.0 Based on 1 review
5 ★ 0
4 ★ 1
3 ★ 0
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Excellent Performance, Good Sound!

Three of the lead singers here (Windgassen, Stolze, and Hotter) were in Solti's classic studio performance of this opera. They are just as good on this occasion, better in fact because they are in a live performance and can be more spontaneous. Stolze's cackling Mime will not please some, but I think he brings the lovably evil dwarf to life. Both Windgassen and Hotter are in good voice and pace themselves admirably.Shuard sings a beautiful Brunnhilde, the voice steady and sure. On this occasion she may have been slightly indisposed as her top notes aren't as confident as they normally were. She gets the C in "Ewig war ich" by the skin of her teeth, nails the three high Bs securely, but ducks the final (admittedly optional) C. Langdon continues his role of Fafner from Das Rheingold and his firm, deep bass suits the role well. He doesn't bother with the scripted yawn or roars though, a little disappointing. Joan Carlyle not only sings beautifully as the Woodbird, but one can actually understand her words - no mean achievement as the text is difficult to articulate. With her rich contralto, Guy is terrific as Erda as is Kraus as Alberich. Solti is less fussy than he is in the studio recording.The sound may not be sumptuous, but is very listenable. I look forward to the Gotterdammerung from this cycle!
Report