Wagner

Excerpts from Siegfried & Meistersinger

Flagstad, Suthaus, Hotter; Rankl, E. Kleiber
1949-1950

Regular price $17.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Excerpts from Siegfried and Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg

I came across some fragments of Wagner operas from 1949 to 1950 which offer a tantalizing glimpse into what was truly a golden age of singing. The first is a complete recording of Act III of Siegfried from 1949 and featuring Kirsten Flagstad and Set Svanholm (I have offered this performance previously in a truncated version that did not include the Erda and Wotan scene.) The sound has some patchy moments which come and go throughout. Even in her 50s, Kirsten Flagstad’s voice was still gleaming and she nails the first notoriously difficult high C effortlessly (she opts out of the final high C.) She is well matched by Set Svanholm’s clarion tenor voice as Siegfried. The disc offers another performance of the two in the final duet from Siegfried from the following year. Although this performance is not complete, Lastly, I came across a series of excerpts from a performance of Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg from Buenos Aires, 1949 conducted by the great Erich Kleiber. Kleiber brings a light touch to Meistersinger with tempi leaning towards the brisk side of the spectrum and he extracts some excellent articulation from the orchestra. These excerpts include both of the Preludes as well as a portion of the Preislied sung effortlessly by Ludwig Suthaus, a portion of David’s music sung by Anton Dermota, a stirring ”Wacht auf!” and the finale of the opera sung by Hans Hotter. Of the three performances, the Meistersinger is in the best sound and is a wonderful find for all of the Erich Kleiber fans out there.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.5 Based on 6 reviews
5 ★ 3
4 ★ 3
3 ★ 0
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Great Performances, Good Sound!

I had heard most of the 1949 performance of Siegfried from an earlier Opera Depot set (OD# 10921) devoted to Flagstad and Parsifal. Here we get the entire third act from that performance with Kenneth Schon and Edith Furmedge as Wotan and Erda. Neither is as interpretively interesting as some others, but neither one wobbles either. They're voices are firm and strong. Rankl makes several cuts in both performances: the traditional one in the Wanderer/Siegfried scene and a chunk of the final scene where Brunnhilde has her doubts (no "Dort seh' ich Grane"). No matter: Flagstad is in typically excellent voice, her tone firm, steady, and beautiful, the top notes secure (she sings the lower C option at the end both times). Svanholm is also very good, if a little blank emotionally. His voice is admirably steady too and he never barks. The sound is very listenable in both, the 1950 performance very clear though a splice to a noisier source just after "Ewig war ich" begins is a little disappointing (the better source returns before the end).The Meistersinger excerpts are in very good sound, but frustratingly brief. Nevertheless Suthaus and Hotter are excellent and the elusive Hoerner is heard in Eva's last solo line.For the Wagner aficionados!
Report
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Grammar Correction to Below

Their voices are firm and strong.
Report
George P.✓ Verified Buyer

Greece

Overall rating

George Papadopoulos

Great and rare stuff
Report
Fritz D.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

Fritz Dr.Lorber

very good compilation
Report
J B.✓ Verified Buyer

Australia

Overall rating

J Brown

Valuable historical recordings, their issue is much appreciated
Report
Gérard S.✓ Top Reviewer

France

Overall rating

Gérard STEIN

un cast de rêve
Report