Wagner

Siegfried

Hopf, Lindholm, Roar, Pampuch; Wich
Düsseldorf, 1974

Regular price $26.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Siegfried

Düsseldorf may not be the first city that comes to mind when considering Europe's great opera centers, but this performance of Siegfried proves that its artistic forces can more than hold their own. With a strong cast of seasoned Wagnerians and an orchestra that rises admirably to the opera's formidable demands, this is a performance of notable strength and vitality. Under the deft baton of Günther Wich, the reading is surprisingly sprightly, balancing clarity and momentum throughout Wagner's sprawling score.

Hans Hopf may not bring youthful color to the title role, but his experience and vocal security—especially impressive given he was nearing 60 at the time—make for a reliable and committed Siegfried. Leif Roar brings refined lyricism to the Wanderer, offering a vocal elegance and a strikingly secure top range that is rarely heard in this role. Berit Lindholm, in her brief but radiant appearance at the opera's close, steals the show with gleaming high Cs and a beautifully shaped "Ewig war ich".

The sound is generally pretty good, though there are around eight brief drop-outs throughout the performance.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.3 Based on 3 reviews
5 ★ 1
4 ★ 2
3 ★ 0
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Fine Performances, Recessed Sound!

The Dusseldorf 1974 Ring cycle continues here with a better-than-expected Siegfried. It is hard to believe Hopf was pushing 60 when he sang this Siegfried. His was never the most mellifluous voice and he could sound woofy, but he knew how to pace himself and had a great technique. The top A he produces on "Siegfrieds Schwert" at the end of Act One is sustained brilliantly and to great effect. Pampuch is a characterful Mime who sings his role rather than declaiming it. He gets off a great top B in Act One and makes music out of Mime's chattery music in Act Two. Roar uses his handsome tone very effectively. There were times when I just sat back and listened to his bel canto singing with the greatest enjoyment. Rintzler is a superb Alberich (a pity his Rheingold Alberich from this cycle hasn't emerged complete) and Malcolm Smith sings Fafner with a steady, beautiful bass. He doesn't indulge in any of Fafner's scripted yawns or roars, but that may have been the director's decision. Cornell, an American mezzo taken from us way too soon, is an impressive Erda and Lindholm continues her fine Brunnhilde though here she just touches the final top C. Wich conducts one of the fastest Rings I've ever heard - don't get in his way!!The sound is listenable, but the voices are farther away than most of us would like. There are also bits and pieces of orchestral music missing here and there. Wich makes the standard cut in the Wanderer-Siegfried scene in Act Three.
Report
Karl K.✓ Top Reviewer

Germany

Overall rating

Karl Heinz Konrad

ich finde es wunderbar solche Aufnahmen hören zu können. Auch wenn die Aufnahme Qualität nicht sehr gut ist. Der Düsseldorfer Ring zeichnete sich durch ausgezeichnete Sänger aus. Pampuch hat den Mime noch jahrzehnte nach seinem Debut gesungen. Hans Hopf als Siegfried muss man live erlebt haben um seinen Leistungen gerecht zu werden. Er war der letzte Heldentenor mit einer strahlenden Höhe und einem ausgefeilten Piano. Lindholm und Roar waren guter Durchschnitt. Die Düsseldorfer Symphoniker spielten unter Wich nicht immer mit einer idealen Lautstärke. Insgesamt eine für Wagner Liebhaber interessante live Aufnahme.
Report
Fritz D.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

Fritz Dr.Lorber

Lindholm/Hopf: marvellous!
Report