Wagner

Siegfried

Hopf, Nilsson, Neralic, Marschner; Cluytens
Milano, 1963

Regular price $26.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Siegfried

André Cluytens' reading of Siegfried is a revelation—fleet, luminous, and remarkably transparent. Under his baton, Wagner's orchestration often feels lighter than air, without ever sacrificing dramatic momentum.

Hans Hopf makes the role of Siegfried sound deceptively easy, dispatching its punishing vocal lines with strength and clarity. Birgit Nilsson is in peak form, her voice blazing with power and brilliance. She brings thrilling authority to Brünnhilde, capturing both the grandeur and the vulnerability of the final scene.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

3.5 Based on 2 reviews
5 ★ 0
4 ★ 1
3 ★ 1
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Great Performance, Some Sound Issues

If the sound on this recording was as good as the performance, we'd really have something to enjoy. Alas, that is not the case. The real problems don't begin until about halfway Act Two just as Siegfried's famous horn call is finishing. The eerie orchestral passage that ushers Fafner onto the stage is missing. Either someone had to turn over the tape or it was lost in transmission. From there until the end of the act the source tape is unsteady, afflicted with wow and flutter. Similar problems intrude in Act Three just as Brunnhilde is waking up. Fortunately, it clears up and the last 15 minutes of the opera are relatively problem- free.The singers themselves give stirring performances. Hopf is a wooly, but likable Siegfried, especially in Act Three, where his vulnerability at meeting a woman for the first time is very touching. Marschner is an excellent Mime who really sings his part. Neralic is a decent if unremarkable, Wanderer and Siewert a good, if slightly past her prime Erda. Van Mill is a grouchy Fafner who sings and roars well (we'll never know if he yawned on coming out of the cave since that section is missing from the tape.) Lorand is fine as the Woodbird and Andersson a formidable Alberich. Nilsson is in great shape and offers her usual thrilling top notes. Cluytens leads a performance that doesn't drag, assisted by some beautiful orchestral playing.For fans of the singers and Cluytens, but I've warned you about the technical issues!
Report
Vincenzo M.✓ Verified Buyer

Italy

Overall rating

Cluytens Nilsson

Great conducting by Cluytens and beautiful playng by Orchestra della Scala , great Nilsson, others so and so ( Marschner good Mime ) . An important document , anyway, it would be nice, to have that complete Ring.
Report