Wagner

Die Walküre (excerpts)

Grob-Prandl, Lemnitz, Suthaus, Hermann, Greindl, Böhm
Buenos Aires, 1950

Regular price $9.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Die Walküre — Excerpts

This recording offers a brief but tantalizing glimpse of some great artists whose careers just missed the proliferation of recordings. Ludwig Suthaus, possibly the most recorded of the main singers, was a tenor whose voice was equally admirable for its power as its lyricism (traits that can often seem at odds with one another). Unfortunately, in the excerpts on this recording, we never get to hear Tiana Lemnitz’s slender, shimmering soprano tackle Sieglinde’s most passionate music, but her few utterances in the opening scene suggest that she is a Sieglinde to be reckoned with. Gertrude Grob-Prandl also regrettably has very little music besides a portion of her impassioned Act III plea to Wotan to encircle the rock with fire which, although short, is worth the price of the set. Josef Hermann, fortunately, treats us to the entire final scene. The whole thing is brilliantly conducted by Karl Böhm who brings a fire to the pacing that must have been very refreshing in an era where Knappertsbusch and Furtwängler dominated. As a bonus I have included substantial excerpts from a 1965 performance of Die Walküre conducted by Karl Böhm and featuring Birgit Nilsson, Theo Adam, Leonie Rysanek and James King.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.7 Based on 6 reviews
5 ★ 4
4 ★ 2
3 ★ 0
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
Gerald H.✓ Verified Buyer

Austria

Overall rating

Wagner: Die Walküre (excerpts) - Grob-Prandl, Lemnitz, Suthaus, Hermann, Greindl, Böhm. Buenos Aires,

Great, great, great!
Report
David M.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Passionate Wagner from Buenos Aires

Ludwig Suthaus dominates these fragments of "Walker" with his firm-toned, manly Siegmund, one of the best ever committed to disc. The power of his voice and interpretation are difficult to overlook. Opposite him, Tiana Lemnitz is a sensitive Sieglinde. Karl Bohm seconds them with passionate, flexible conducting, a more impulsive interpretation than we are used to from him. Gertrud Grob-Prandl's thrilling soprano is only very briefly heard but Josef Herrman gives an impressive account of Wotan's apostrophe to his favorite daughter. Finally, with regard to the disputed Hunding, it is probably Jorge Danton, stumbling over the German text. The complete cast list, including the manifold Valkyrie daughters can be seen here: http://www.operas-colon.com.ar/cgi-bin/wwwisis/[in=aaa2.in] The excerpts from the opera are the opening of Act I to just before Siegmund's Narration; the Ride of the Valkyries (wild!); and Wotan's Farewell.
Report
Gunther T.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

Gunther Teckelmann

Very interesting cast singing together in this recording!
Report
Charlie E.✓ Verified Buyer
Overall rating

Charlie Edwards

Pretty amazing how consistent Böhm is in Bayreuth 15 years after the Buenos Aires performances - his direction was always so intense and driven, the only caveat being thet the Todesverkündigung scene is too fast and perfunctory (1965). I wish there was more of the glorious Grob-Prandl - I've actually never heard anything to compare with her combination of athletic,tireless singing and warmth of expression - a cross between Nilsson and Flagstad! And any recording with Suthaus is worth hearing - such virility and tragic utterance. By the way it's definitely NOT Greindl as Hunding in Buenos Aires - doesn't even sound like a native German speaker. King, Rysanek and Nilsson in 1965 are pretty astonishing too.... though better known from the 1966/7 recordings - here it's a little more hectic and messy but pretty exciting. King is SO much better here than in Solti's studio-bound effort the same year.
Report
Herbert B.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

Herbert Burger

its interesting to have this, because there are no studio recordings
Report
Gérard S.✓ Top Reviewer

France

Overall rating

Gérard STEIN

très intéressant
Report