Wagner

Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg

Ridderbusch, Kollo, Janowitz, Schreier, Lagger, Leib, Meyer; Karajan
Salzburg, 1974

Regular price $34.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg

A performance of Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg is always an event, even if it is a revival. When you add Herbert von Karajan to the mix you know that you are in for a real spectacle, both aurally and visually. Karajan doesn’t disappoint in conveying the opulence and pomp of Wagner’s only comedy, but where he is at his best is during the intimate moments particularly the prelude to Act III. Karajan is able to evoke all of Hans Sachs’ wistfulness from the cello section of the Berlin Philharmonic who sing their line with no less intensity than the great singers on the stage. This is just one of the many memorable moments of this performance. Karl Ridderbusch gets a chance to show his softer side as Hans Sachs and reveals a musical sensitivity that I didn’t know he had in him. René Kollo is an ideal Walther von Stolzing combining the impetuous rashness as well as the poetic lyricism of the character. Gundula Janowitz brings a pure tone to the role of Eva but tends to tire vocally during some of the higher lying passages. In typical fashion, Karajan recruits some excellent singers for the smaller parts including Kerstin Meyer as Magdalene, Peter Lagger as Pogner, Manfred Jung as Eisslinger and in a bizarre turn he divides the two Night Watchman solos between two singers, the latter taken by none other than Gerhard Stolze. The performance is captured in superb stereo sound.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.7 Based on 17 reviews
5 ★ 13
4 ★ 3
3 ★ 0
2 ★ 1
1 ★ 0
Manfred B.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

Meistersinger - Osterfestspiele 1975

Habe ich live im großen Festspielhaus 1975 bei den Osterfestspioelen gesehen. Phänomenal!! Die Jahresangabe auf der CD ist falsch. Es war nicht 1974, sondern 1975.
Report
Frank L.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Wonderful

This is a great Meistersinger. Janowitz is wonderful, Karajan is great and so is Kollo. The sound is top notch. Enjoy this performance.
Report
Bruce G.✓ Verified Buyer

Canada

Overall rating

Bruce Gillespie

Wonderful performances
Report
Harald H.✓ Verified Buyer

Austria

Overall rating

Harald Hoyer

an excellent production
Report
Guenter S.✓ Verified Buyer

Austria

Overall rating

Guenter Schober

super live Performance, i did see it in 1974
Report
Vincenzo S.✓ Verified Buyer

Italy

Overall rating

Vincenzo Scerra

Grat performance, the Berliner can compete with Dresden Statskapelle chooses for the recording in 1970.
Report
Richard B.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

Richard Bernas

This live performance is better cast and more engaged than Karajan's studio recording. The lyric scenes are especially enjoyable and Ridderbusch has a the vocal richness and gravitas that Sachs requires.
Report
Peter H.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Peter Heisler

Meistersinger is, to my ears, been better served by live performances than by studio recordings despite limitations in sound quality. This performance features an excellent cast and is better conducted than Karajan's Dresden recording. Janowitz is radiant and Ridderbush is excellent.
Report
Luigi B.✓ Verified Buyer

Italy

Overall rating

Luigi Belloni

It's Excellent, particularly thanks to Karajan Direction
Report
Michael A.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

Michael Asser

This is in many respects, save that of sound quality, superior to Karajan's 1970 Dresden studio recording. Karl Ridderbusch had a real Sachs voice, beautiful, and warmer in tone than Paul Schoffler, with the true bass register when needed. I have not heard his equal in my lifetime; one has to go back to the legendary Friedrich Schorr to find his superior. The rest of the cast, especially Janowitz, are fine except for the greatly overrated Kollo, whom I heard live at Covent Garden, and whom I thought was just as coarse then. HvK is his usual fine self in this music.
Report
Fabio Z.✓ Verified Buyer

Italy

Overall rating

Fabio Zanzucchi

stunning. I believe Karajan is definitive in the Meistersinger
Report
Giovanni M.✓ Verified Buyer

Italy

Overall rating

giovanni martini

Absolute reading Karajan in perfect agreement with singers, chorus and orchestra excellent.
Report
Damian B.✓ Verified Buyer

Australia

Overall rating

Damian Brown

Wonderful
Report
Hans H.✓ Verified Buyer

Germany

Overall rating

Hans Heukenkamp

Glad I could add Salzburg 1974 to my collection of "Meistersinger" recordings. Kollo, Janowitz and Schreier were absolutely convincing.
Report
Frank L.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Frank Leto

I loved this performance.Janowitz was beautiful and Kollo ardent as Walter. Karajan's conducting was wonderful. Great performance
Report
Gerard L.✓ Verified Buyer

France

Overall rating

gerard LUTZ

beautiful
Report
Thomas H.✓ Verified Buyer

Italy

Overall rating

Thomas Brian Hodgkiss

The performance would be virtually ideal if it were not for Kollo's crude singing. He should have stuck to pop.The prize song is bumpily sung with no poetry - some mastersinger!I'm glad to have the performance for the other singers, but, given my dislike of Kollo, will probably listen to it in 'bleeding chunks'.
Report