Strauss

Elektra

Nilsson, Lindholm, Ericson, Saeden, Jehrlander; Klobucar
Stockholm, 1965

Regular price $17.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Elektra

Despite being the reigning dramatic soprano of her time—arguably of any time—Birgit Nilsson avoided the role of Elektra until she was nearly 50. This Stockholm performance captures her first run in this punishing role, proving that the wait was well worth it. Her voice here sounds just slightly smoother than in the later Solti recording, and her characterization is already well-formed. One of Nilsson’s most underappreciated qualities was her outstanding musicianship. Elektra is not only fiendishly difficult to sing, but its ever-shifting patterns, meters, and complex harmonies pose immense challenges. Nilsson deserves special praise for delivering such a musically assured performance. Berit Lindholm sings with fervor as Chrysothemis, while Barbro Ericson impresses by both maintaining attractive tone and conveying Klytämnestra’s grotesque decay. The sound quality is only fair. The singers come through beautifully but much of the detail in the orchestra gets lost.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

3.7 Based on 3 reviews
5 ★ 0
4 ★ 2
3 ★ 1
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
Jeffrey S.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

An archival recording. Deserves MUCH better.

Unfortunately the fidelity is lousy. The 3 ladies are recognizable, just. Ericson and Lindholm transcend the boomy sound with their extraordinary ability to convey vocal intensity and tonal beauty against great odds.Nilsson's Elektra reminds me of Flagstad's Brünnhilde at La Scala in 1953, her golden tones cutting through the terrible recording when none of her excellent colleagues could manage not lose themselves in the murky ambiance. A terrible tease, this Elektra. Perhaps Sterling cds should remaster this, something they did so beautifully with Kobukar's Salome with Laila Andersson-Palme's great assumption of the title role.If you want Nilsson's pre-Solti Elektra you can find it, if you are intrepid, her first Vienna outing in 1965 with Böhm, Rysanek, Resnick and Waechter.I will keep this document, until a remastered version appears. All thanks to Opera Depot for providing this tantalizing clue to a great performance deserving of exhumation.
Report
Bo W.✓ Verified Buyer

Sweden

Overall rating

Electra

Very good performance!
Report
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Stunning First Elektra From Nilsson, Listenable Sound

I don't know whether or not this was Nilsson's very first Elektra or if it's just a performance from her first run in the role. She understandably chose a house where she was very comfortable to try out this difficult role and the Royal Swedish Opera gave her excellent colleagues to heighten the occasion.She is incredibly secure vocally; there's nothing in the score the fazes her. The two top C's shine like beacons of light in a storm, the tricky intervals sung with unerring confidence. Nilsson already has a solid grasp of the character; she would become more specific with later performances. Lindholm is a fine contrast to her as Chrysothemis - not as neurotic or blazing as Rysanek, but singing with accurate musicianship and great involvement. Ericson sings Klytemnestra with beautiful tone and lots of extra-musical noises that highlight her character's fear and decay. The offstage screams are blood-curdling though I don't know whether or notEricson does them herself. Saeden and Jehrlander are first-rate in the small, but important roles of Orest and Aegisth. The rest of the cast (unlisted) is very impressive. Klobucar leads a taut, effective performance.The sound is a little muffled, there are some occasional bursts of static, and short breaks where someone may have had to turn over the tape. But none of these minor faults prevent one from enjoying the performance.If you love Nilsson, you should have this in your collection!
Report