Rossini

Semiramide

Sutherland, Simionato, Ganzarolli, G. Raimondi; Santini
Milano, 1962

Regular price $17.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Semiramide

This recording could star no one but Joan Sutherland. Caught at the height of her powers, she sings this performance of one of her greatest roles with unyielding power, impeccable fluidity and flawless accuracy. Beside her is Giulietta Simionato in a role that, although perhaps not an ideal fit, finds her in top form. Their duet in act two is a match of truly great voices. Next to them, Wladimiro Ganzarolli sounds a bit threadbare, but he delivers his mad scene with fiery intensity. Gianni Raimondi, with his arias cut, has little to do, but what is there is quite notable. This run of Semiramide played an instrumental role in returning the opera to the active repertoire, as the forces at La Scala were forced to re-assemble the opera from Rossini's manuscripts. Gabriele Santini leads the evening, and if his tempi err on the side of too slow, he does not let the momentum lag either. The sound is generally solid, and although the performance has a few cuts more than the purist in me would like, it is easy to forget when the glorious leading ladies are singing.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.9 Based on 12 reviews
5 ★ 11
4 ★ 1
3 ★ 0
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
Peter

United States

Overall rating

Goldstar Standard

I agree. It is shameful to cut or shorten any opera and especially when you have a voice such as Raimondi's but with all the cuts - this performance, with this powerhouse cast, is *the* one. Better than any other you'll find and those include the later performances of Joan in 64 and 65 on here. The casting here is one to envy and Joan only gives us that one glorious 'E' among other stellar moments...worth it.
Report
Horia G.✓ Top Reviewer

Romania

Overall rating

GIOACHINO ROSSINI'S SEMIRAMIDE

SEMIRAMIDE IS JOAN SUTHERLAND AND JOAN SUTHERLAND IS SEMIRAMIDE. A(NOTHER) MUST HAVE! ThHE TENO'S NAME IS GIANNI RAIMONDI, NOT GIANNI ROLANDI (IN THE CRITICAL NOTES).
Report
Horia G.✓ Top Reviewer

Romania

Overall rating

GIOACHINO ROSSINI'S SEMIRAMIDE

I AM TERRIBLY SORRY FOR THE TYPO MISTAKES... SO... SEMIRAMIDE IS JOAN SUTHERLAND AND JOAN SUTHERLAND IS SEMIRAMIDE. A(NOTHER) MUST HAVE! THE TENOR'S NAME IS RAIMONDI, NOT ROLANDI. THANK YOU SO MUCH!
Report
Mauro S.✓ Verified Buyer

Italy

Overall rating

Excellent and reliable Seller, always rich of beautiful recordings: definitely recommended.

Naturally the main virtue of this historical performance is the debut of Dame Joan Sutherland as Semiramide, really great in this marvellous and extremely difficult Belcanto role; and if in the future performances conducted by the most competent M° Richard Bonynge she will be even more outstanding (also thanks to the presence of the unrivaled Arsace of Mme Marilyn Horne), in this production she sung much more recitatives, and with an excellent interpretative accent, making this first recording not only a precious document, but also a necessary musical evidence of her imperishable Art.
Report
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

The Two Leading Ladies Make This Worth Soecial!

Back before there was Sutherland and Horne, there was Sutherland and Simionato. No, Simionato didn't quite have Horne's coloratura ability, but what she does have is more than adequate. Perhaps more importantly she blends well with Dame Joan, both singers listening and responding to each other, challenging the other to give her best. In addition, Sutherland sings a dazzling "Bel raggio" (still in key here), crowning it with a bell-like high E. The two leading men are very good, but this type of music wasn't really in their training and requires a different style than that to which they were accustomed. Raimondi joins Sutherland on a great high C at the end of Act One. Ganzarolli actually handles Assur's coloratura better than I thought he would. This music must have seemed very daunting at the time (1962). It still is difficult, but now we have singers more capable of Rossini's rapid coloratura demands. The original ending is used here (where Semiramide is killed instead of Assur); I prefer it to Bonynge's use of the "lieto fine" that Rossini wrote later. The sound is from a very good broadcast source and is pitched correctly too.Santini cuts the heck out of the score, but get this for the two leading ladies, both of whom sing like the divas they were!
Report
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Correction: The Two Leading Ladies Make This Worthwhile!

Correction of previous review title.
Report
Chris W.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

opera

the singers were fantantic the opera is also great but not performed very often in opera houses
Report
Sam B.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

SEMIRAMIDE SUCCEEDS IN SPITE OF CUTS

Overall excellent performance & the sound is great for the period. The only drawn back are the cuts. Sutherland is in top form. Simionato is a treasure, however - do not look for Arsace's IN SI BARBERA as it's not here! The gentlemen are also up to snuff! A worthwhile addition to anyone's library & if you are a SEMIRAMIDE connoisseur… a must!
Report
Jeffrey✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

The stars aligned to capture Sutherland, Simionato and Rossini!

Enough cannot be said to describe the vocal mastery that transpires here. Sutherland and Simionato, each is resplendent, together miraculous! Ganzarolli is excellent, dark and fluid throughout. Raimondi is so striking, the omission of his arias is regrettable. Several ensembles and choruses are also cut. Santini may lack “elan vital”, but he partners the singers with care. Sound is very good.
Report
Renaat B.✓ Verified Buyer

Belgium

Overall rating

renaat van Beeck

Great performance
Report
Kenneth S.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Kenneth Sherrill

Worth it for the amazing performances by Sutherland and Simionato. Their second act duet was so good that I stopped the recording and played the duet again. Sadly, the work is very heavily cut. Both tenor arias are gone, much of the choral music is gone. Conducting is not good at all.
Report
Master K.✓ Verified Buyer
Overall rating

Master Ken

Well worth the price but not a Semiramide of choice. Still, worth buying and hearing. The work is very heavily cut and Santini's conducting isn't very good. BUT Sutherland and Simionato are amazing. Fascinating to hear Simionato, so totally different from Horne and others but dramatically amazing and vocally brilliant. The second of the two duets with Sutherland was so amazing that I had to stop the recording and play the duet again.
Report