Puccini

Turandot (In English)

Shuard, Kaart, Collier, Rouleau, Tree, MaCDonald; Pritchard
London, 1960

Regular price $17.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Turandot

This recording of Turandot harkens back to the era in which Covent Garden would present all of their operas in English. The superb cast is headed by Amy Shuard who brings both bone-chilling intensity along with vocal warmth which one rarely hears in this role. Hans Kaart, a tenor who was unknown to me, is outstanding as Calaf and Marie Collier brings her signature pathos to the role of Liù.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.3 Based on 4 reviews
5 ★ 2
4 ★ 1
3 ★ 1
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Exciting Turandot in Good Sound!

I don't know what the source of this performance was, but it sounds like an early in-house tape given the slightly recessed quality of the voices. It may be an early house tape too. Either way this is a very well sung Turandot that was probably performed complete. I say probably because there are a few sections missing. The beginning of Act Two, scene two fades out and returns just before Turandot begins "In quests reggia" and the music after Timur's lament in the last act disappears though we do get the rest of the opera including the normally cut "Dal primo pianto". Some of the English translation is discernible, most of it is rather hazy.Shuard is terrific as Turandot as is the previously unknown to me Hans Kaart. He sings with beautiful, steady tone with a great top register that easily encompasses the optional top C on "No, no, principessa altera". What a tragedy he died so young! Collier is excellent. She is rushed by Pritchard through "Perche un di" in Act One, but gives melting accounts of her arias. The ministers are first-rate as is the Mandarin. Unfortunately, most of Altuom's part has been lost. Chorus and orchestra are lead well by Pritchard who shows again that Puccini wasn't really his thing.Turandot lovers will enjoy this as will fans of the singers.
Report
Robert S.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

Hans Kaart

He was a theatre and film actor as well as an opera singer. The only man ever to have played Shakespeare's Falstaff and sung Verdi's Otello apparently.
Report
David F.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

David Fletcher

a fantastic performance,excellent cast
Report
Joseph B.✓ Verified Buyer

United Kingdom

Overall rating

Joseph Brand

A fascinating document - the last ever performances in English at Covent Garden - and the last of finest production of Turandot with magnificent designs by Leslie Hurry who was an outstanding theatrical designer. Unfortunately there are a number of cuts - the traditional ones in the 1st scene of act two, but then everything between the end of that scene and In questa reggia; and everything between Liu's suicide and the end of that scene (none of this would have happened at the actual performance). But the whole of Alfano's duet (version2) is included so we do get the whole of Shuard's contribution and with Kaart and Pritchard the riddle scene is so thrilling the set becomes very desirable. A good trio of ministers, Collier not quite right as Liu (she was to sing her first Tosca the same season at Sadler's Wells). Kaart was a very fine performer and sang Calaf many times with Shuard at Covent Garden starting in Dec. 1958 on the occasion of Puccini's centenary. Unfortunately at this particular performance he and Pritchard disastrously part company in Non piangere Liu - bot otherwise he's in splendid voice. He was tragically killed in a car crash not long after these performances.
Report