Dallapiccola

Il Prigioniero (In English)

Treigle, Cassilly, McNight, Stern, Macurdy; Stokowski
1960

Regular price $9.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Il Prigioniero

Listen to a Sample of Tosca:

I am always fascinated to hear Italian music post-Puccini. Some like Montemezzi carried on many of the traditions whereas Zandonai's palate seemed to borrow equal parts from French, Italian and German styles. Luigi Dallapiccola's Il Prigioniero seems to have taken the most from Alban Berg's playbook. Although there are aspects of atonality throughout the opera, a keen ear will note that, like Berg's music, it is still rooted in a tonal center. Likewise the nightmarish subject matter of an abject prisoner, alienated from society and tormented by superiors certainly contains many of the same themes as Wozzeck. That said, his Italian roots do manage to come through in the form of the occasional melody. This performance, sung in English, features the great Norman Treigle in the title role. Treigle's ability to fully inhabit a role makes him an ideal exponent, and the doomed optimism that he conveys goes a long way to make the ending all the more tragic. Richard Cassilly was also a good choice as the jailor and grand inquisitor alternating sweet lyricism with dramatic heft making the motivations of the character seem all the more uncertain.

To fill out the rest of the CD I have included this glimpse of a wonderful performance of Tosca featuring the great Eleanor Steber. Steber was nearing the end of her career when this performance was made. Although some of the bloom of her early days may have worn off, she still sings Tosca with ruthless abandon delivering, among other things, a spine-tingling high C. She is joined by Richard Cassilly as Cavaradossi and a young Marilyn Zschau as the Shepherd.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.5 Based on 4 reviews
5 ★ 3
4 ★ 0
3 ★ 1
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
Franck M.✓ Verified Buyer

France

Overall rating

Intéressant, mais…

Pour la direction de Stokowski et la distribution vocale des deux rôles principaux : Anne McKnight (La Mère) et Norman Treigle (Le Prisonnier) ; orchestre et chœur dans le lointain.
Report
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Rare Performance in Great Sound!

Anything of Norman Treigle's that can be found should be made available to the public. Here he is vocally at his freshest and is both terrifying and heartbreaking as the prisoner who is tortured, teased with the possibility of freedom, and ultimately betrayed by the Powers that Be. Anne McKnight sings the mother's difficult lines extremely well with beauty as well as passion. Richard Cassilly shows why he was so valued back in the 60's and 70's, singing with firm tone and dramatic awareness. Stokowski (!) leads this short classic with immense authority and drama. Dallapiccola may have seemed avant garde back at the time of its premiere, but most audiences are used to his style from other musical theater pieces and from film scores.The pairing of this with Act Three of Tosca makes sense because Cassilly sings in both and thematically both deal with a prisoner caught in the throes of political fascism. Steber may be slightly past her prime, but the top still rings out with accuracy and she provides some fine drama at the end. A very young Marilyn Zschau is heard briefly as the Sheperd - perhaps she was already dreaming of singing the title role one day.The sound (transferred from records) is excellent. The Tosca is from an in-house tape, but the voices are very clearly heard over the orchestra.
Report
Jim J.✓ Verified Buyer
Overall rating

Jim Johnson

Norman Treigle is why I love opera. I saw Faust with him in 1962 in New Orleans and have been hooked ever since. This recording shows why. His voice is so expressive and filled with anguish. His diction is superb. He fills his character with all the traits that make you believe he is The Prisoner---a true singing actor.
Report
Brian M.✓ Verified Buyer
Overall rating

Brian Morgan

As the biographer of Norman Treigle, I can assure you that the recording under review was, until now, the rarest of extant performances of the great singing-actor. The annuals of the New York City Opera do not claim this 1960 production to have been broadcast, so its provenance is unknown to this reviewer, yet the sound-quality is excellent.Conducted by Leopold Stokowski and directed by Christopher West (in his company debut), this was the \""professional\"" American premiere of Luigi Dallapiccola's dodecaphonic opera, set during the Spanish Inquisition. Treigle had one of his greatest roles in this work, and his co-stars, Richard Cassilly and Anne McKnight, were also utterly extraordinary.At the time, Harriett Johnson wrote that the production bespoke \""an atmosphere of terror....\"" In fact, the New York press corps universally proclaimed it a great success.The Mobile Press had reported that \""Il prigioniero\"" was to have been \""scheduled for recordings with Stokowski shortly.\"" This was not to be, so we are greatly in the debt of Opera Depot for publishing such a moving account of a profoundly disturbing masterpiece.
Report