Menotti

Amahl and the Night Visitors (In Italian)

Simionato, Cordova, Lazzari, Capecchi, Corena; Stokowski
Firenze, 1952

Regular price $5.95
Select Format
Add to Wishlist Added to Wishlist

Amahl e gli Ospiti Notturni

Although born in Italy, Gian Carlo Menotti always considered himself an American composer. However, hearing this performance of Amahl and the Night Visitors sung in Italian does a lot to reveal his roots. To say that Giulietta Simionato is luxury casting as the mother is an understatement. For an opera that is overwhelmingly mounted in church basements and other humble venues, it is refreshing to hear a great singer in this role and does a lot to show Menotti's genius. The cast also includes Agostino Lazzari, Renato Capecchi and Fernando Corena as a triumvirate of truly regal Magi. It is conducted by none other than Leopold Stokowski. The recording also includes an interview with Menotti, in English, about mounting this particular performance. There is a substantial amount of material cut out of this performance (all sanctioned by Menotti as revealed in the interview.) I have filled out the rest of the CD with arias by Simionato.

Recently viewed

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Example product title

Customer Reviews

Share your experience with fellow collectors

4.0 Based on 3 reviews
5 ★ 1
4 ★ 1
3 ★ 1
2 ★ 0
1 ★ 0
David R.✓ Top Reviewer

United States

Overall rating

Heart-rending Performance Despite a Huge Cut!

In the interview before the performance Menotti speaks of the difficulty of finding an Amahl in Italy. But he found a fine Amahl in Alvardo Cordova who is sincerely charming and touching. Simionato is superb as the Mother. Her sobs after she is caught trying to steal the gold are heart-breaking. The three kings are very strongly acted and sung (look at those names!) Stokowski leads a beautiful performance that is, unfortunately, missing the entire middle section including the quartet for the Mother and Kings and the villagers' chorus and dance. Apparently there wasn't enough time alloted for the performance, leading me to think that the entire tape might be available in someone's archive. Who knows? The sound is very decent monaural.Andy suppliments the opera with excerpts from roles Simionato rarely sang. They are delightful, but I'd give all of them for a complete copy of the Amahl!
Report
Matthew G.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

The Italians lay claim to Amahl

This Italian-language recording is a revelation on two counts: Giulietta Simionato gives a glorious performance as Amahl’s Mother, and the orchestra, under Stokowski, shows Menotti for the imaginative master he was. It’s a shame that the score—heard here shortly after the live world premiere, in English, on American television--is so ruthlessly cut. No quartet for the Mother and the Three Kings, arguably the very heart of the opera, contrasting the child sought by the kings and the child she cherishes. Also missing: the entire scene with the shepherds. Honestly, how does survives is well worth 5 stars—and the bonus tracks of Simionato in often unexpected repertoire (Mozart!) are ravishing.
Report
Paul G.✓ Verified Buyer

United States

Overall rating

Paul Gudas

It's an interesting - if partial - souvenir of what must have been a VERY interesting performance
Report